The Journal of Human Rights

The Journal of Human Rights

Public Policy-making in the Situation of Conflicting Patients' Medical Rights, Relying on the Principles of Ethics and Human Rights

Document Type : Research Article

Authors
Bagher Shamloo 1
Davood Bagheri 2
1 Associate Professor, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran. (Corresponding Auther)
2 Phd candidate in law, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.
10.22096/hr.2023.562072.1505
Abstract
In the face of crises such as the rapid spread of contagious diseases, the ravages of war, and the devastation of earthquakes, medical professionals often find themselves in a dire predicament. Resources and treatment facilities at their disposal are simply insufficient to cater to the needs of all patients. The ethical and legal quandary that arises in such situations, of categorizing patients and determining the order of medical service, is a pressing issue that involves policy makers, doctors, and patients alike.
This article delves into a thought-provoking question: What should be the guiding principles in patient prioritization? Should the distribution of health resources be solely based on clinical criteria, which are primarily consequentialist, or should egalitarian criteria determine the order of patient care? And how do we balance the need to protect patients' human rights with the adopted criteria?
The answers to the aforementioned questions have been obtained by adopting the analytical-descriptive method and using library resources. The results show that the answers to the above issues should be based on the maximum respect for the patients’ human rights, on a clinical and non-clinical composite approach, and by giving weight to the egalitarian-based retrospective and consequences-based prospective components.
Keywords
Conflict of Rights
Health Resources
Distribution
Prioritization

Subjects

Bibliography 
‌‌Ansari, Bagher. “Human Rights Dimensions and Challenges of Covid 19.” Legal Research Quarterly 25, Law & covid-19 no.2 (June 2022): 53-91. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.29252/jlr.2022.226840.2178.
Beauchamp, Tom L, and James F Childress. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. New York: Oxford University Press, 2013.
Biddison, Daugherty, Howard Gwon, Alan Regenberg, Monica Schoch, and Eric Toner. “Maryland Framework for the Allocation of Scarce Life-sustaining Medical Resources in a Catastrophic Public Health Emergency.” accessed August 23, 2020. http://bioethicstoday.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Daugherty-Maryland-framework-PH-emergency-2017.pdf.
Bognar, Greg. “Priority Setting and Age.” In Prioritization in Medicine, Edited by Eckhard Nagel, and Michael Lauerer 163-179. New York: Springer, 2016.
Cropper, Maureen L, Sema K. Aydede, and Paul R. Portney. “Preferences for life saving programs: how the public discounts time and age.” Journal of Risk Uncertain 8, no.3 (May 1994): 243-265.
Désiré Court, Joseph. “Scene of Deluge.” accessed August 23, 2022. https://narrativepainting.net/?p=517.
Farrell, Timothy W, Leslie Francis, Teneile Brown, Lauren E Ferrante, Eric Widera, Ramona Rhodes, Tony Rosen, Ula Hwang, Leah J Witt, Niranjan Thothala, Shan W Liu, Caroline A Vitale, Ursula K Braun, Caroline Stephens, and Debra Saliba. “Rationing Limited Healthcare Resources in the COVID-19 Era and Beyond: Ethical Considerations Regarding Older Adults.” Journal of the American Geriatrics Society68, no. 6 (Jun 2020): 1143-1149. https://dx.doi.org/10.1111%2Fjgs.16539.
Hirose, Iwoa. Egalitarinis. New York: Routledge, 2015.
Jobegs, Sussane, Rasita Vinay, Valerie A Luyckx, and Nikola Biller-Andorno. “Recommendations on COVID-19 triage: international comparison and ethical analysis.” Bioethics34, no. 9 (Nov 2020): 948-959. https://dx.doi.org/10.1111/bioe.12805.
John, Tyler M, and Joseph Millum. “First Come First Served?.” Ethics130, no. 2 (January 2020): 179-207. https://dx.doi.org/10.1086/705763.
Loewy M.D, Erich H., and Roberta Springer Loewy. Textbook of Healthcare Ethics. New York: Springer, 2005.
M.John, Tyler, Joseph Millum, and David Wasserman. “HOW TO ALLOCATE SCARCE HEALTH RESOURCES WITHOUT DISCRIMINATING AGAINST PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES.” Economics and Philosophy33, no. 2 (July 2017): 161-186. https://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0266267116000237.
Minnesota Department of Health. “Ethical Framework to Allocate Remdesivir in the COVID-19 Pandemic.” accessed July 29, 2020. https://www.health.state.mn.us/diseases/coronavirus/hcp/remdesivir.pdf.
Mirmoosavi, Seyed Ali. “Obligations and Responsibilities of State In Relation to Human Rights.” The Journal of Human Rights16, no.1 (Spring and Summer 2021): 25- 52. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.22096/hr.2021.134788.1237.
Mosadeq Rad, Ali Mohmmad, Mahmood Zamandi, and Ebrahim Jaafaripooyan. “Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Health Interventions: A Critical Review.” Journal of School of Public Health and Institute of Public Health Research18, no.1 (Spring 2022): 29-50. [In Persian]
Mounk,Yascha. “The Extraordinary Decisions Facing Italian Doctors.” The Atlantic, accessed March 25, 2020. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/03/who-gets-hospital-bed/607807/.
Nagel, Thomas. Equality and Partiality. Translated by Javad heidari. Tehran: Farhang Nashr Noe Publication, 2020. [In Persian]
Parrillo, Joseph E, and R. Phillip Dellinger. Critical Care Medicine: Principles of Diagnosis and Management in the Adult. Philadelphia: Elsevier Inc, 2013.
Parvari, Peyman. “The transition from philosophy to methodology, a new reading of the phenomenology method: the foundation of philosophical approaches and implementation steps.” The Journal of Sociology Studies 12, no.44 (December 2019): 87-106. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.30495/jss.2019.669587.
Perry, Runen, and Tal Z.  Zarsky. “Queues in Law.” IOWA LAW REVIEW 99, no. 4 (May 2014): 1595-1658.
Rafighi, Somayeh, and Mohammad Asghari. “The Role of Phenomenology of Merleau- ponty in Medicine.” Journal of Philosophical Investigation 11, no.20 (August 2017): 117-140. [In Persian]
Rasekh, Mohammad. “Foundations and the System of Public Health Law in the Emergency Situation.” Legal Research Quarterly24, no. 95 (November 2021): 57-80. [In Persian] https://dx.doi.org/10.29252/jlr.2021.221972.1914.
Rawls, John. A Theory of Justice. Translated by Morteza Noori. Tehran: Markaz Publication, 2016. [In Persian]
Saadi, Mosleh Ebne Abdollah. Kolliate Saadi. Edited by Mohamad Ali Forogi. Tehran: Hastan Publication, 1999. [In Persian]
Sandel, Michael. What Money Can't Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets. Translated by Hasan Afshar. Tehran: Markaz Publication, 2018. [In Persian]
Seyedi, seyed amir hosein, and Seyed Mohammad Mahdi Ghamami. “Management of Social Harassment Caused by the Crisis in the Light of the Law Prevalence (Case study: COVID-19 Disease).” Societal Security Study12, no.65 (Spring 2021):161-181. [In Persian]
Shamloo, Bagher. “Preventive Criminal Policy Review in the Light of Epidemic Covid - 19 and Chaos Theory.” Legal Research Quarterly   23, LAW and COVID- 19 no.1, (September 2020): 111-142. https://dx.doi.org/10.22034/jlr.2020.185110.1655
Stone, Peter. The Luck of Draw. New York: Oxford University Press, 2011.
Tolchin, Benjamin, Hull, Sarah C, Kraschel, Katherina. “Triage and justice in An Unjust Pandemic.” Journal of Medical Ethics 47, no. 3 (March 2021): 200-202 https://dx.doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2020-106457
Vaughn, Lewis. Bioethics Principles, Issues and Cases. New York: Oxford University Press, 2016.
Walzer, Michael. Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality. Translated by Saleh Najafi. Tehran: Sales Publication, 2015.
Send comment about this article
Enter Name.
Enter a valid email address.
Enter a vaid affiliation.
Enter comments (At leaset 10 words)
CAPTCHA Image
Enter Security Code Correctly.
The Journal of Human Rights
Volume 19, Issue 1 - Serial Number 37
Spring and Summer 2024, Issue 37
July 2024
Pages 31-51