The Journal of Human Rights

The Journal of Human Rights

In search of a Fair Label for Forced Marriage at the International Criminal Court

Document Type : Research Article

Author
Assistant Professor, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
In early 2021, Dominic Ongwen was found guilty of crimes against humanity through, inter alia, forced marriage. It was the first conviction of forced marriage in the history of the International Criminal Court. In the trial proceedings, it came clear that labelling forced marriage would be challenging. The Defense argued in favor of categorizing this conduct under sexual slavery. On the contrary, the Judges considered forced marriage as an independent conduct that should be prosecuted under the category of other inhumane acts. Taking into account the principle of fair labeling, this article seeks a fair label for forced marriage as an international crime. For this purpose, following the conceptualization of forced marriage, the fair labelling principle is studied. Then, this article analyzes labeling forced marriage as an indistinct crime from pure sexual crimes. As will be discussed, due to the expressive function of the Court, forced marriage should be charged independently to represent separate harms inflicted to its victims.
Keywords

  1. A) Books & Articles

Ahmadreza, Tohidi and Azadeh Dadashi. “International Criminal Tribunal Approach to Forced Marriage as Sexual Violence.” Journal of Legal Research 18, no. 39 (2019): 7-40. [In Persian]

Ambos, Kai. Treaties on International Criminal Court. Vol. II. NewYork: Oxford University Press, 2104.

Amiri, Fatemeh. “Development of International Criminal Law in Light of Criminalization of Forced Marriage.” International Law Review 27, no. 43 (2011): 267-289. [In Persian]

Ashworth, Andrew. “The Elasticity of Mens Rea.” in Crime, Proof and Punishment: Essays in Memory of Sir Rupert Cross. Edite. by C. F. H. Tapper. London: Butterworths, 1981.

D’Ascoli, Silvia. Sentencing in International Criminal Law. The UN Ad Hoc Tribunals, 2011.

De Vos Dieneke. “Confirmation of Charges Hearing in Ongwen Case: Hopeful Signs for Gender Justice?” INTLAWGRRLS (February 4, 2016).

Deguzman, Margaret. “Giving Priority to Sex Crime Prosecutions: The Philosophical Foundations of a Feminist Agenda.” International Criminal Law Review 11, No. 3 (February 2011): 515-528.

Dias, Talita. “Retroactive Recharacterization of Crimes and the Principles of Legality and Fair Labelling in International Criminal Law.” DPhil Thesis, University of Oxford, 2019.

Dumbryte, Asite. “Till Death do Us Part: Forced Marriage as an International Crime.” Revista do Instituto Brasileiro de Direitos Humanos 13, (2013): 11-28.

Eboe-Osuji, Chille. International Law and Sexual Violence in Armed Conflict. Leiden: Nijhoff, 2012.

Goodfellow, Nicholas. “The Mis categorization of Forced Marriage as a Crimes against Humanity by the Special Court for Sierra Leon.” International Criminal Law Review 11, No. 5 (October 2011): 831-867.

Grey, Rosemary. “The ICC’s First ‘Forced Pregnancy’ Case in Historical Perspective.” Journal of International Criminal Justice 15, No. 5 (December 2017): 905–930.

Hall, Christopher, and Stahn Carsten. “Article 7.” In The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: A Commentary, Edite. by Kai Ambos. CHBECK: Nomos, 2016.

Hosein, Mir Mohammad Sadeghi and Zeynab Laki. “A new approach to criminal referral in the light of the fair labeling principl.” Journal of Criminal Law Research 7, no. 2 (2019): 255-285. [In Persian]

 Kool, Renée. “Iris Haenen, Force and Marriage: The Criminalization of Forced Marriage in Dutch, English and International Criminal Law.” Human Rights Law Review 15, No. 2 (June 2015).

Moghaddasi, Mohammad Bagher & Zahra Ameri. “Forced Marriage: From Prohibition to Criminalization.” Criminal Law Doctrines 13, no. 12 (2016): 169-198. [In Persian]

Oosterveld, Valerie. “Forced Marriage: Terminological Coherence and Dissonance in International Criminal Law.” William and Marry Bill of Rights Journal 27, (2018): 1263-1282.

Schabas, William. The International Criminal Court: A Commentary on the Rome Statute. Oxford University Press, 2016.

Sliedregt, Elis van. “The Curious Case of International Criminal Liability.” Journal of International Criminal Justice 10, No. 5 (August 2012): 1182–1185

Stahn, Carsten. Justice as Message. NewYork: Oxford University Press, 2020.

Zaidi, Arshia, and Muhammad Shuraydi. “Perceptions of Arranged Marriage by Young Pakistani Muslim Women Living in a Western Society.” Journal of Comparative Family Studies 33, No. 4 (September 2002): 495-514.

Zakerhossein Mohammad Hadi. Pre-Trial Procedure of the International Criminal Court: Situation Selection Process. Tehran: The SD Institute of Law Research and Study, 2020. [In Persian]

Zakerhossein, Mohammad Hadi. Situation Selection Regime at the International Criminal Court. Brussels: Intersentia, 2017.

  1. B) Documents

ECCC, Case 002 Closing Order (September 15, 2010).

ECCC, Trial Chamber, Khieu Samphan case, Judgment (November 16, 2018).

ICC, Remarks of Judge Song President of the ICC (December 10, 2014).

ICC, Al Hassan case, PTC I, Rectificatif à la Décision relative à la confirmation des charges portées contre Al Hassan (November 13, 2019).

ICC, Katanga case, PTC I, Decision on Confirmation of Charges (October 14, 2008).

ICC, Muthaura Case, Public Redacted Version Decision on the Confirmation of Charges Pursuant to Article 61(7) (a) and (b) of the Rome Statute (January 23, 2012).

ICC, Ongwen case, PTC II, Decision on the Confirmation of Charges against Dominic Ongwen (March 23, 2016).

ICC, AI Hassan case, PTC I, Warrant of Arrest for AI Hassan Ag Abdou Aziz Ag Mohamed (March 27, 2018).

ICC, Ongwen case, Further Redacted Version of “Defence Brief for the Confirmation of ChargesHearing” (March 3, 2016).

ICC, Ongwen case, TC IX, Trial Judgment (February 4, 2020).

ICC, Katanga case, Judgment pursuant to Article 74 of the Statute (March 7, 2014).

ICC, Katanga case, TC II, Summary of Trial Chamber’s Judgment (March 2014).

ICTR, Kunarac case, Appeals Chamber Judgment (June 12, 2002).

ICTY, Trial Chamber, Kupreškić case, Judgement (January 14, 2000).

ICTY, Banović case, Sentencing Judgment (October 28, 2013).

ICTY, Tadić case, Judgment (May 7, 1997).

SCSL, Taylor case, Judgment (May 18, 2012).

SCSL, Trial Chamber, Judgment AFRC case (June 20, 2007).

SCSL, Trial Chamber, Judgment AFRC case, Dissenting Opinion of Justice Doherty (June 20, 2007).

SCSL, AFRC Case, Opinion by Justice Sebutinde (June 20, 2007).

SCSL, AFRC Appeals Judgment (February 22, 2008).

SCSL, AFRC Case, Appeals Chamber Judgment (February 22, 2008).

SCSL, Appeals Chamber, Prosecutor v. Issa Hassan Sesay et al., Judgment. (October 26, 2009).

 

 

 

 

Send comment about this article
Enter Name.
Enter a valid email address.
Enter a vaid affiliation.
Enter comments (At leaset 10 words)
CAPTCHA Image
Enter Security Code Correctly.